Follow Us

Log in

For Business        For Academia         For Practitioners        For Students       Jobs Board

About NLA        Why NLA        Join NLA

The Paradox of Tribalism

12 Oct 2023 3:14 PM | David Robertson (Administrator)

Tribalism is a complex concept within leadership and social dynamics, potentially enhancing or hindering a leader's effectiveness. To navigate this paradox, leaders must carefully consider their alignment with tribes, the nature of their affiliations, and the values that guide their actions. Essentially, leaders and followers face three options – A, B, or C.

Option A involves uncritically joining a tribe without examination and allowing that tribe to dictate your thoughts and actions. This approach can be complex, as it risks subsuming individuality and critical thinking under the influence of the tribe. Leaders who follow this path may prioritize groupthink over independent thought, potentially leading to decisions and actions that do not align with their core values or vision.

Option B entails valuing the thoughts and philosophies of tribes based on merit and adapting one's existence to match the tribe's criteria. While this approach may seem more flexible, it still carries risks. For example, it can lead to leaders or followers compromising their core principles and values to align with the tribe's agenda. Moreover, it may result in a lack of authenticity, with members becoming chameleons who adapt to their tribes without maintaining a strong sense of self.

Option C, which encourages people to value their own thoughts and philosophies and shape their existence and affiliations based on thoroughly examined and contrasted personal beliefs and convictions, is the ideal choice for those seeking lasting impact, ideal outcomes, and authenticity. This approach centers on maintaining individual agency, critical thinking, and unwavering commitment to vision and values.

Choose Wisely

Leaders who choose Option C prioritize their own core beliefs and convictions above tribal pressures. They recognize the importance of independent thought, visionary leadership, and the role of ideas and principles in guiding their actions. Such leaders are less swayed by the allure of titles or the superficial aspects of tribal affiliations. They are also more likely to inspire and motivate others towards a vision.

Moreover, in pursuing Option C, leaders carefully select the tribes they align with, ensuring that these affiliations resonate with their vision and values. This choice reinforces their leadership by surrounding themselves with a supportive tribe that shares their objectives, propelling the leader and the tribe toward common goals.

Option C encapsulates the essence of effective leadership: a balance between maintaining individual agency and guiding and inspiring others. Leaders who embrace this approach empower their team members to make independent decisions while offering guidance and a shared vision. This dynamic fosters a collaborative and cohesive environment where individuals thrive, the team prospers, and collective goals are achieved. However, this notion requires significant context. It's definitely not as easy as it may seem.

The Necessary Contexts

One of the critical aspects of tribes is that they provide individuals with a sense of belonging and identity. People naturally seek to connect with others who share similar beliefs or goals, and tribes are a means through which this connection is established. Whether it's a tribe formed around a religious faith, a professional field, or a hobby, these groups give individuals a sense of community and a platform to express their individuality within the collective identity.

The thing that leaders need to understand is that tribes often serve specific purposes, and these purposes can vary widely. For example, a tribe of Constitutionalists may unite to protect a particular right, while a group of gamers may come together to enjoy playing video games. In both cases, the tribe exists to pursue a particular cause or interest. Within these tribes, individuals can contribute their unique skills, ideas, and perspectives, ultimately enhancing the overall effectiveness of the group in achieving its goals.

However, it's important to note that individuals can belong to or align with multiple tribes simultaneously, as their interests and values are multifaceted. If they choose correctly, these affiliations do not define or limit them but enrich their lives by allowing them to engage with diverse ideas and experiences. Tribes serve as a testament to the human desire to connect, collaborate, and find common ground with like-minded individuals while maintaining their own unique identities. However, that is both a vital clue and a warning for leaders.

In leadership, one of the most common pitfalls is the blind trust placed in titles and tribal affiliations. All too often, leaders are swayed by the allure of prestigious designations or the familiarity and social pressures of belonging to a particular group. However, a more enlightened approach to leadership suggests that the focus should be on the underlying ideas, values, and principles rather than the superficial trappings of titles, pressures, or the allure of tribes. In some cases, leaders may completely avoid tribalism due to their inherent flaws.

Forward-thinking and visionary leaders understand that the essence of effective leadership lies not in the titles or affiliations they hold but in the substance of their beliefs and the principles they uphold. This distinction is an important one. In essence, it is not the fancy designation that makes a leader but the ideas, wisdom, and strategies they bring to the table. Effective leadership hinges on inspiring and guiding others through a compelling vision, transcending the limitations of titles and superficial associations.

Moreover, if leaders feel compelled to join or create a tribe, then they are well-advised to select the tribe they align themselves with carefully. In leadership, a "tribe" can be seen as the team, organization, or community a leader surrounds themselves with. Leaders must choose a tribe that resonates with their vision and aligns with their core values. In this case, a carefully selected tribe can be a source of support and reinforcement for the leader's mission.

By selecting a tribe that shares their vision and values, leaders can foster a sense of unity and collective purpose. Doing so strengthens the leader's resolve and creates a sense of common direction within the tribe. In doing so, leaders ensure that their energy and efforts are channeled toward a shared objective rather than being diluted by tribal conflicts or misalignment. However, tribes evolve, and change is constant and forever. This point is a critical warning that leaders must continually evaluate the position and direction of the tribes they have chosen. This way, leadership becomes a force that transcends the superficial and embraces the profound.

The Clarity

Leadership is a multifaceted situation that demands a delicate balance between leading one's life and allowing followers, or "tribes," to lead theirs. The core principle in this dynamic is to maintain individual agency while guiding and inspiring others. This duality is essential for effective leadership and is the cornerstone of a successful leader-follower relationship.

At the heart of leadership is individual agency, the capacity of each person to act independently and make their own choices rather than becoming compliant drones. A good leader recognizes that fostering individual agency within their tribe while avoiding "groupthink" is crucial. They empower their team members to take ownership of their tasks, make decisions, and develop their skills. By doing so, leaders cultivate a sense of responsibility and accountability and encourage creativity and innovation within the team.

However, while critically important for both leaders and followers, leadership isn't solely about autonomy. It involves guiding, inspiring, and providing a sense of direction to the tribe. Leaders should share their knowledge and experiences to assist their team members in personal and professional growth. While preserving individual agency, they must also create a supportive environment that fosters collaboration and shared goals.

While balancing individual agency and leadership can be difficult, it is a sign of an adept leader. It's a testament to their capacity to lead by example, respect their team's autonomy, and offer guidance when necessary. In doing so, they create a harmonious leadership dynamic where individuals can flourish, the tribe can thrive, and collective goals can be achieved. Ultimately, this equilibrium is a cornerstone for effective leadership in any setting.

At the same time, we must understand that tribalism, a deeply ingrained aspect of human nature, can foster a sense of belonging and cooperation within a group while posing a significant challenge to collaboration between different groups or tribes. Our world is increasingly interconnected and reliant on cooperation, so it is crucial to understand how tribalism can act as a double-edged sword, sometimes preventing productive collaboration across tribal lines. To address this issue, it becomes essential to not only recognize the divisive tendencies that come with tribalism but also to emphasize the importance of shared ideas or common goals to transcend the boundaries of tribal identities.

Overcoming Divisive Tendencies

Tribalism is the instinctive human tendency to form groups based on shared cultural, ethnic, or ideological affinities. The warning is that while this can promote a sense of unity, it often leads to an "us versus them" mentality, where individuals view members of other tribes as outsiders or even adversaries. In collaboration, this can manifest as distrust, bias, and a reluctance to work with those from different tribes. The sad truth is that these tribal identities can become obstacles to effective collaboration, as they can lead to misunderstandings and conflicts that hinder progress. This breakdown is also a symptom of "vision loss." Hence, the idea or vision must supersede the "tribe" or identity.

In other words, focusing on shared ideas or common goals provides a means to overcome the limitations of tribalism. When individuals and groups come together around a shared vision, purpose, or objective, it transcends tribal identities and creates a common ground for cooperation. The utility of this fact cannot be overstated. This approach fosters a sense of inclusivity, allowing people from diverse backgrounds to contribute their unique perspectives and talents toward a common aim. The power of shared ideas or goals lies in their ability to unite individuals across tribal lines, encouraging them to set aside differences and work together for the greater good.

Collaboration across tribal identities is increasingly essential. By recognizing the influence of tribalism and emphasizing shared ideas and goals, various tribes can bridge divides and harness the collective potential of diverse groups. This shift in perspective promotes collaboration and offers a path toward a more interconnected and harmonious future where shared objectives take precedence over tribal affiliations.

So, yes, we want to build groups of individuals with a common goal. However, this utility is paradoxical because it can lead to isolationism and a lack of cooperation with other tribes. Hence, the vision or goal must be more pronounced than the tribe itself, and the vision must always be the central focus.

The idea that people are often inspired by the underlying idea or goal rather than the tribe itself is a fascinating perspective on human motivation and behavior. While tribal affiliations and group identities have played a significant role throughout history, it is increasingly evident that individuals are drawn to movements, causes, and ideologies because of the principles and objectives they represent rather than just being part of a specific group. This shift in focus toward ideas and goals has significant implications for our understanding of human psychology, social dynamics, and how people engage with the world. 

A group of random people can get us further than we can go alone. However, a team with a vision is a powerful force. One key aspect of this idea is that it highlights the power of purpose. People are more likely to invest their time, energy, effort, and resources in something they believe in passionately. This idea is particularly evident in social and political movements, where individuals rally behind a cause, not simply because they identify with a particular group but because they are deeply committed to the ideas and objectives that the movement represents.

This is our clue because it suggests that a cause's strength can transcend traditional tribalism's boundaries and unite people from diverse backgrounds and affiliations. We have seen numerous examples of this in recent history. The aftermath of the attacks on September 11th is an excellent example of this.  A common foe and threat resulted in collaboration, support, and a sense of belonging among individuals inspired by the same ideas or goals. In this way, tribes can emerge as a natural consequence of shared circumstances and inspiration.

The Accuracy Problem

Accuracy doesn’t have a tribe.

A big problem with tribalism is that, sometimes, tribalism can stifle accuracy. Accuracy is a fundamental aspect of human cognition and inquiry. It's a universal concept that underpins the pursuit of knowledge and understanding in various domains, from science and academia to everyday decision-making. However, the interesting aspect of accuracy is that while it is not inherently tied to a specific tribe, some groups or communities may place a higher emphasis on it in their quest to achieve their particular goals or promote their ideas.

Conversely, there are leaders who prioritize their tribe's agendas or the consolidation of power over accuracy and truth. This tendency often stems from the perceived necessity of garnering support for their initiatives. In these cases, leaders may intentionally manipulate information or present a skewed version of reality to maintain or increase their influence within their group. This behavior can lead to distorted facts or a lack of transparency. However, once discovered, this results in an erosion of trust within their tribe, ultimately compromising the long-term success and ethical standing of their leadership.

Accuracy is paramount if outcomes matter because it is the backbone of strategy. Accuracy demands rigorous attention to detail, verification, dissenting ideas, stress testing, and peer review to ensure that the knowledge produced is as accurate as possible. Leaders need accuracy to formulate the best strategies. Hence, leaders must learn how to identify accuracy and adhere to it. Like quality journalists, we must understand the importance of fact-checking, corroborating sources, and providing and consuming accurate information while rejecting astroturfing and emotionally biased information.

Of course, there is another element to consider—partial accuracy. For example, different political parties or movements may emphasize accuracy to various degrees. Partial truths can be problematic because they do not offer a full scope or balanced assessment of the situation. Leaders need to understand that some tribes may prioritize rigorous fact-checking and data-driven decision-making, while others prioritize emotional appeals and ideology over empirical accuracy for the sake of distorting perceptions.

This truth illustrates that accuracy can vary; it is not a universal value within tribes. This is to say that a group's specific goals and priorities can influence the importance of accuracy. Hence, leaders must continually evaluate the goals and objectives of the tribe and examine contrasting information for better contexts. 

A Bigger Paradox

Leaders must understand that tribalism is a complex and often paradoxical social phenomenon deeply ingrained in the human experience. On one hand, it can be a powerful force that fosters a sense of belonging, unity, and collaboration among individuals. It's an intrinsic part of human nature to seek out connections with like-minded individuals, as this can provide emotional support, a shared sense of purpose, and an overall sense of security.

Again, the utility of this is vital for leaders to understand. When harnessed positively, tribalism can lead to cohesive communities and a powerful sense of identity. In such cases, it acts as the glue that binds people together, fostering mutual understanding and empathy among group members. When had, this typically results in better outcomes. 

However, the paradox of tribalism becomes apparent when this natural inclination takes a darker turn. While tribalism can promote collaboration within a group, it often does so at the expense of creating divisions between different groups. This "us versus them" mentality can lead to prejudice, discrimination, and conflict. Moreover, it can result in the omission of vital facts and perspectives. Historically, countless conflicts, from wars to social and political divisions, have been fueled by tribalism. When groups become too insular and exclusive, they can alienate those who "don't belong" to their tribe, exacerbating such divisions.

It's crucial to recognize the dual nature of tribalism and its potential for both positive and negative outcomes. It's also important to understand what allows us to use it as a tool while guarding against its potential negatives. Acknowledging this paradox will enable us to harness the positive aspects of tribalism, such as fostering a sense of belonging and collaboration, while actively working to mitigate divisive tendencies.

One of the best ways to achieve this is by emphasizing shared values and common goals across various tribes. This approach can help bridge the gaps and reduce conflicts, leading to a more harmonious and inclusive situation. By embracing the positive aspects of tribalism while actively addressing its divisive potential, we can navigate this delicate balance to create a more interconnected and cooperative world. However, that is easier said than done.

To understand this concept, we must examine effective team building. Effective team building is a fundamental aspect of successful organizations and projects. At its core, it revolves around having a clear vision and assembling a tribe of individuals who rally around that common purpose. As alluded to, when a team's members identify with and buy into this vision, it fosters a strong sense of belonging and cohesion, which is crucial for achieving ideal outcomes. 

Additionally, emphasis on the vision allows for "cross-tribal collaboration." For example, if two tribes have a common foe, they may unite and collaborate to address the threat. The vision is what allows different groups to come together for a common cause rather than remaining divided and ultimately conquered collectively. 

The point is that a clear vision serves as the foundation upon which the team or coalition should be built. It provides a sense of direction, defines the objectives, and outlines the values and principles guiding the team's actions. This clarity of purpose ensures that all team members move in the same direction and empowers them with a sense of purpose. When team members understand the 'why' behind their work, it motivates them and makes them feel like they are part of something meaningful.

However, you will note that the tribe itself was secondary to the vision. Instead, the tribe merely becomes the vehicle that gets us to our destination. In that metaphor, it must be understood that if that vehicle breaks down, the desired destination remains, and the individuals can continue on. 

The Vision is Paramount

Building a tribe around a shared vision is akin to creating a community. Team members who share common goals and values become more than just colleagues; they become a tightly-knit group of individuals who support and trust one another. This shared identity fosters a profound sense of belonging, where each member feels appreciated, valued, and essential to the team's success. This, in turn, cultivates a cohesive atmosphere where collaboration is natural, communication is effective, and conflicts are resolved with understanding.

Effective team building begins with a clear, compelling vision that unites individuals with a common purpose. This shared vision creates a tribe, a community of like-minded individuals, because it nurtures a sense of belonging and cohesion. When team members feel part of something bigger than themselves, it boosts morale and drives them to work together harmoniously, resulting in remarkable outcomes. Effective team building, therefore, hinges on not just assembling a group of individuals but fostering a shared identity and purpose that binds them together.

The vision must always be the focus. A vision gives the team a sense of direction, purpose, and a destination to strive for. When each team member aligns with this vision, they start to identify themselves as part of a particular project or organization and as members of a shared tribe with a unique culture, values, and objectives. When team members don't align with that vision, they are easier to identify and remove.

The sense of identity deepens as the team progresses towards realizing the shared vision. This evolving identity is driven by the common purpose, values, and goals that members

have embraced. The team becomes more than just a group of individuals working together; it transforms into a cohesive tribe where each member recognizes their role and importance in achieving the vision. Moreover, other tribes that align with that same vision become collaborative allies.

Leadership requires vision focus. While it's vital for leaders to connect with and inspire their teams, they must also clearly understand their overarching vision to stay motivated and lead with purpose. If a leader loses sight of this, the leader can become more focused on groupthink and tribal power. The warning is that the dynamics of a tribe can be powerful and persuasive, often exerting a significant influence on the leader's decision-making and direction. In other words, it's easy for leaders to become swept up in the immediate needs and desires of the group, which may lead to short-term gains but can compromise the long-term vision. Leaders solely influenced by the tribe might lose sight of the bigger picture and, over time, struggle to maintain their motivation and sense of purpose. This loss of focus is likely to infect the team. Moreover, it can lead to a breakdown in collaboration with allies with similar goals.

Leaders must be acutely aware of the nuances at play to prevent this. They need to balance the need to connect with their team and understand their concerns with the ability to keep their eye on the long-term goals and values that guide the organization. More importantly, they must continually remind their teams of why the tribe exists. This balance is crucial for maintaining motivation. Leaders who are grounded in their overarching vision can provide their team with a sense of direction, purpose, and stability, even when faced with the ebb and flow of group dynamics and changing circumstances.

Leaders who stay motivated by the overarching vision rather than solely by the tribe itself often inspire their teams to do the same.

Focusing on the higher purpose and long-term goals and eliminating what distracts them from that vision encourages a sense of shared commitment and passion. This approach helps create a more resilient, adaptable, and forward-thinking organization, as the leader and the team become less likely to be swayed by short-term group dynamics. Successful leaders understand the nuances of balancing their connection with the tribe and their commitment to the broader vision. This balanced approach keeps them motivated and fosters a culture of lasting purpose and achievement within their organization. 

Privacy Statement
Terms of Use 
Registered 501(c)(6)

Powered by Wild Apricot Membership Software